I build and look after websites for Australian tradies and small service businesses. Every site is built by me - no outsourcing, no account managers. More about Mike.
Most Australian tradies have tried a lead platform at some point - hipages, ServiceSeeking, Airtasker, Oneflare. Some swear by them. Plenty have quit them. The honest answer is that they solve one problem well and create a different one, and the comparison worth making isn't "which is better" but "which jobs is each one good for".
What lead platforms genuinely do well
Work from a standing start. No website, no reviews, no history - you can be quoting jobs the week you sign up.
Fill quiet weeks. When the diary has holes, buying a few leads is a fast way to plug them.
Test a new service or area. Cheap way to find out whether there's demand for bathroom renos two suburbs over.
Demand already exists there. Plenty of homeowners start on those apps rather than Google.
If a platform is paying for itself, don't cancel it out of principle. The problem isn't that they don't work - it's what happens when they're the only thing you've got.
What they cost you that isn't on the invoice
You pay per lead, forever. Every job starts with a cost, and that cost goes up over time. A website's cost doesn't rise with the number of enquiries.
You're quoted against, side by side. The same lead often goes to several trades, so you're competing on price before anyone's seen your work.
Paid leads aren't always ready leads. Some are tyre-kickers, some are price-shopping, some have already picked someone.
The customer belongs to the platform. Your reviews, your job history and your reputation sit in their account, not yours. You can't take it with you.
Nothing compounds. Stop paying and the enquiries stop the same day. Two years of spend leaves you exactly where you started.
What your own website does that a platform can't
You're the only trade on the page. No side-by-side quotes, no race to the bottom on price.
You show your actual work. Photos of finished jobs, your own reviews, your licences and your area - the things that win the better jobs.
It answers searches with real intent. Someone typing "emergency electrician [suburb]" at 7pm wants a phone number now, not a quote form and a wait.
It works while you sleep, at a fixed cost. Ten enquiries or a hundred - the price doesn't change.
You own it. Your domain, your content, your customer list.
Lead platform
Your own website
Cost model
Per lead, rises over time
Fixed weekly cost
Competing quotes
Usually several trades per lead
You only
Who owns the customer
The platform
You
Reviews build up where
Their profile
Your site and Google
Stops when you stop paying
Immediately
Keeps ranking for a long while
Speed to first enquiry
Days
Weeks, then it compounds
Suits which jobs
Small, price-led jobs
Bigger, trust-led jobs
Search results are where people look when they don't already know who to call - and that's where your own site competes.
The real maths, plainly
Say a decent lead on a platform costs you $30 to $80 depending on the trade and the job size, and you win roughly one in four. That's $120 to $320 in lead cost per job won, every job, forever. Fifty jobs a year and you're spending thousands just for the right to quote.
A website is a fixed cost instead. Mine is $99 to get started, then $45/week once your site is live. The difference is that the fifth enquiry in a week costs the same as the first - nothing extra. See how tradie website pricing actually works if you want the different models compared.
The pattern that works best
The tradies who get this right rarely quit platforms cold. They build their own website first, get it ranking for their suburbs, then wind the paid leads back as their own enquiries grow - keeping the platform on hand for quiet stretches.
Moving from paid leads to your own enquiries
Get a website live with a page for each service you actually want more of.
Add suburb pages for the areas you work, written properly rather than copied.
Ask every happy customer for a Google review - that's what feeds the map results.
Put your website on your ute, quotes, invoices and email signature.
Track where enquiries come from for three months before you cancel anything.
Wind back paid leads once your own enquiries cover the diary.
That's exactly what the Tradie Website Design package is built to do - get you found for your own trade in your own suburbs, so the enquiries come to you instead of being bought one at a time.
Need a Better Website for Your Business?
Want a website that explains your services and shows your work? Take a look at the package, projects and pricing.
See what your website can do. Nothing more to pay until it has been live for 5 weeks.
$99 to get started. Your first 5 weeks are free once your website goes live. After that, it’s $45 a week. Weekly payments start automatically after your 5 free weeks. Cancel anytime.
Common questions
Should I cancel hipages once my website is live?
Not straight away. Give the website a few months to start ranking, track where your enquiries come from, then wind the paid leads back once your own enquiries are covering the diary.
Are platform leads worse quality than website enquiries?
Usually, yes - not because the customers are worse, but because they're comparing several quotes at once. Someone who found your website and rang you has already chosen you.
How long until my own website brings in enquiries?
Generally a few weeks for Google to index and start showing your pages, with momentum building over a few months. See how long SEO takes.
Can I do both?
Yes, and most tradies should for a while. Use paid leads to fill gaps while your own site builds up, then let the website carry the load.